🔗 Share this article

An acclaimed author, a respected historian of the American frontier, has authored a recent volume titled Partners in the West, which delves into the stories of the famed lawman and Doc Holliday. Gardner expresses displeasure with the famous line from a classic cowboy film: “When the tale becomes truth, print the myth.”

“Each researcher uses it, they just repeat it endlessly,” the author remarks cheerfully. “And it’s actually not correct. I wrote a story. I hope people to be absorbed in the era, but I just get so weary of that quote. The myth is legend. It never become fact. People can retell the myth but it doesn't make it reality.”

That Infamous Gunfight at the Corral

In Tombstone, Arizona, on a day in October 1881, Earp and Holliday were took part in a confrontation that is remembered as the Gunfight at the OK Corral. Joined by his siblings, the duo met the outlaw gang, men sought for robbery and cattle theft. In under 60 seconds, three gang members were killed and Doc was hurt, as were Virgil and Morgan Earp.

Even though being one of numerous Wild West clashes between officers and bandits, it became folklore, largely thanks to classic movies including the John Ford film and another renowned film.

Confusion and Contradiction in Eyewitness Testimonies

“A large part of what we learn about it is confirmable,” he remarked of the true battle and its aftermath. “But I consistently go back to one of the most telling statements, and it’s a very straightforward statement. An observer, who observed the shootout, remarked: ‘I don’t know. It was all a blur.’”

Among the people on the scene had conflicting versions. Testimony from the Spicer hearing is also confusing. Witnesses who were friends of the Cowboys were lying, and all account is a bit unique. It’s rare when somebody aligns on any point.

“It was all a blur.” – an eyewitness

“Including the individuals present were bewildered,” Gardner continues. “So it’s really hard to get at it, and it took place in 30 seconds.”

Legend-Building and Hollywood Representations

Wyatt Earp survived into the Hollywood era, passing away in 1929 at the years of eight decades. First depicted on a silent movie film in the 1920s, he later became the focus of significant mid-century films. In relatively recent decades, he has been acted by Kurt Russell in Tombstone and Kevin Costner in the 1994 movie.

He digs through such myth-making to uncover the people underneath. His publications span the range of the Wild West, from a legendary figure and Pat Garrett to the notorious bandit.

Multifaceted Backgrounds of Earp and Holliday

Born in Illinois in 1848, Earp was underage to fight in the civil war, though he tried to do so. When he was two decades old, he was appointed a law officer in Missouri. Missteps were committed. Earp experienced a loss with the passing of his spouse, Urilla, from illness in 1870. Subsequently, as constable, he retained public funds he obtained.

“We can't know why he retained it,” he states. “He runs, and ends up in the frontier. He’s apprehended for taking a mount, and then he’s in Illinois, and he’s operating a establishment. Finally he heads back to the frontier, and he ends up in Wichita, Kansas.”

Despite his checkered background, Earp shone as a police officer. The press praised him repeatedly. In one case, he detained a inebriated man who had a large sum on him. Earp safeguarded the cash for the drunk and handed it back when he let go him from jail.

Contrasting Personalities of the Duo

Gardner highlights the stark difference between the two. Earp was driven, wanting to improve himself and reach positions like county sheriff. Holliday, originating in Griffin, Georgia in 1851, was a tooth doctor turned risk-taker. In contrast to Earp, he did not show signs of becoming stable.

“Holliday just journeys from one saloon to the following,” he observes. “He doesn't really transform. And a portion of that’s his obsession to gambling. Part of that is tuberculosis, coping with that and using substances, whether it’s with drink or eventually opium.”

Impact and Historical Significance

Brothers of the Gun illustrates a compelling element of the American West: the tension between authority and crime, and the attempts of authorities to exert control over newly forming societies. The extent of bureaucracy that resulted from a violent incident – hearings, affidavits, directives for compensation – might astonish those familiar with simplified versions of the period.

Additionally, Earp and Holliday were entangled in partisan factional conflicts. He was a member of the GOP, while Tombstone sheriff Johnny Behan was a Democrat, creating a rivalry for power and office.

Finally, he avoids to romanticize these figures. Earp and Doc passed time on each side